- To prepare chutney, slice jalapenos. Roughly chop mint leaves, coriander sprigs and basil sprigs. Blend together sliced jalapenos, chopped leaves, lemon juice and salt into a smooth paste. Transfer in a bowl. To prepare one portion, slit the 2 pavs with one side intact and open. Spread some chutney on one side of the pavs, reserving remaining for serving and some mayonnaise on the other side. Grate some red cheddar cheese, cheddar cheese and Emmental cheese on the mayonnaise side of the pavs. Sprinkle some crushed peppercorns on top and cover with the other side of the pavs. Heat a non-stick grill pan and brush some olive oil and butter. Place the sandwiches and grill from sides till golden brown and cheese melts.